I tried to trip Astra up, but it was having none of it. I asked it what famous art gallery we were in, but it refused to hazard a guess. I asked why it had identified the paintings as replicas and it started to apologize for its mistake (Astra apologizes a lot). I was compelled to interrupt: “No, no—you’re right, it’s not a mistake. You’re correct to identify paintings on screens as fake paintings.” I couldn’t help feeling a bit bad: I’d confused an app that exists only to please.
When it works well, Astra is enthralling. The experience of striking up a conversation with your phone about something you’re both looking at feels fresh and seamless. In a media briefing yesterday, Google DeepMind shared a video showing off other uses: reading an email on your phone’s screen to find a door code (and then reminding you of that code later), pointing a phone at a passing bus and asking where it goes, quizzing it about a public artwork as you walk past. This could be generative AI’s killer app.
And yet there’s a long way to go before most people get their hands on tech like this. There’s no mention of a release date. Google DeepMind has also shared videos of Astra working on a pair of smart glasses, but that tech is even further down the company’s wish list.
Mixing it up
For now, researchers outside Google DeepMind are keeping a close eye on its progress. “The way that things are being combined is impressive,” says Maria Liakata, who works on large language models at Queen Mary University of London and the Alan Turing Institute. “It’s hard enough to do reasoning with language, but here you need to bring in images and more. That’s not trivial.”
Liakata is also impressed by Astra’s ability to recall things it has seen or heard. She works on what she calls long-range context, getting models to keep track of information that they have come across before. “This is exciting,” says Liakata. “Even doing it in a single modality is exciting.”
But she admits that a lot of her assessment is guesswork. “Multimodal reasoning is really cutting-edge,” she says. “But it’s very hard to know exactly where they’re at, because they haven’t said a lot about what is in the technology itself.”
For Bodhisattwa Majumder, a researcher who works on multimodal models and agents at the Allen Institute for AI, that’s a key concern. “We absolutely don’t know how Google is doing it,” he says.
He notes that if Google were to be a little more open about what it is building, it would help consumers understand the limitations of the tech they could soon be holding in their hands. “They need to know how these systems work,” he says. “You want a user to be able to see what the system has learned about you, to correct mistakes, or to remove things you want to keep private.”